Power Thrust Curves
Got a bit of static strain going on myself. Got pins stickng out of three toes. Not bike related. Very little mobility for 6 weeks. :(
Go get yourself a warm (yuck) bottle of Guiness (don't understand why you brits like that stuff - looks good though) and contemplate.
What about capillary action? It can lift (move or force) water up a cloth without any obvious applied energy or how a magnet can lift a nail (force and change so "work" has been done) so you could calculate the HP required to lift the nail without using up the magnet’s potential energy.
Hope you are feeling better very soon.
Regards,
JAG
Go get yourself a warm (yuck) bottle of Guiness (don't understand why you brits like that stuff - looks good though) and contemplate.
Oh dear oh dear oh dear!!!
Warm Guiness???? Guiness should be served cool. Bitter should be ambient celler temperature, and nasty tastless gassy lager cold so at least it could be refreshing and so good for something.
I'm generaly against the use of force, prefering torque to solve disputes, but if torque doesn't work then it may be applied to prevent beers being served at the wrong temperature - as we all know power works when words fail, I'm sure you get the general thrust of my argument anyway.
JAG
Go get yourself a warm (yuck) bottle of Guiness (don't understand why you brits like that stuff - looks good though) and contemplate.
Oh dear oh dear oh dear!!!
Warm Guiness???? Guiness should be served cool. Bitter should be ambient celler temperature, and nasty tastless gassy lager cold so at least it could be refreshing and so good for something.
I'm generaly against the use of force, prefering torque to solve disputes, but if torque doesn't work then it may be applied to prevent beers being served at the wrong temperature - as we all know power works when words fail, I'm sure you get the general thrust of my argument anyway.
JAG
I have been rightly chastised for showing my ignorance on what I clearly do not know anything about.
Thank you for setting me straight and still being so kind.
burp !
JAG
Warm? That's such a big urban myth about Blighty beer. I can thrust-curve a cold pint of tasty sparkling lager (is there any other tepidity?) down my gullet in ten seconds flat. But then again I'm English, which is different from being British, which is not the same as being European. Britain is made up of multiple countries with different drinking habits. Whilst Guinness is arguably the most popular drink in Ireland, which is actually a Republic nowadays, it's not as popular in British countries such as England, Scotland and Wales. And most certainly not in England, whose national flag is 'not' the Union Jack! Just thought I'd clear those cultural things up! ;-D
Captain - you getting all teary eyed for the home land young man ? :-)
Now I was born, bred and raised in Scotland though my travels have seen me additionally living in USA, Canada and now Czech Republic but still a jock underneath it all. Unlike a lot of my fellow countrymen I am not anti-English in any way and indeed my brother and I were a rare site and sound during the Ashes series in 2005 shouting like mad for England during the epic battle with the Aussies at Edgbaston. I would appear to be bucking trends all over the place as I can't stand Scottish beer, especially the drivel they call lager there and have been a pure Guinness man for all the years that I was living in Britain and could get ready access to the stuff. It is perhaps the reason I am such a fat git too! It's true what they say that it is better in Ireland than anywhere else as it does not travel so well but Scotland is not that far from its home and it was OK. The extra cold stuff is also quite nice, though I prefer it at cellar ambient.
The whole debate about flags etc is one that I have been embroiled in a number of times - legally speaking England, Scotland, Wales and N Ireland are not countries so does that mean we have national flags? I would like to think that we do and that the cross of St Andrew & St George along with the Welsh Dragon and N Irish flag will keep their identity and meaning, even if technically they may not have the status we would like. In saying that, I have no problem with the Union Jack just don't expect me to get excited about that damn blue thing with the yellow stars though.
Anyhoo - Ashonbikes - better throw in a motorcyling element. My friend is just back from service training in Bologna for the new Pannigale and tells me that production will start in April - it will be an eagerly awaited launch and to keep it entirely topical maybe one of the clever boffins on here will make up a thrust curve for it.
Shuggs, cap'n and jag. There's a bit of a real ale boom going on in blighty at the moment. Loads of choice of a wide range of beers, all top quality IMVHO. A lot of it from "down south" too, which is unusual.:D
Two of my favourite bottled beers at the moment are from Aberdeen, and Maryland US of A. They taste equally good served at room temperature or slightly chilled. Whichever takes sir's fancy on the day. Splendid.
Panigale. Have they published power/torque curves yet?
I offered MO elsewhere that the 600 sportsbike should be applauded as the pinnacle of its type. Is the panigale the equivalent in the v twin world?
Captain Scarlet wrote:
"Warm? That's such a big urban myth about Blighty beer. I can thrust-curve a cold pint of tasty sparkling lager (is there any other tepidity?) down my gullet in ten seconds flat. But then again I'm English, which is different from being British,"
What would be the power to weight ratio of moving a pint of lager about sixteen inches in ten seconds flat?
I think you would come up a very slow second compared to a few souls from Newfoundland I have had the honor to meet.
But then again, you are only an Englishman.
Is not the English flag way at the back of the Union Jack?
Thrust curves and beer, what a combination.
JAG
pittsy wrote:
"Panigale. Have they published power/torque curves yet?"
Another great choice.
Light weight with good RWHP in one great handling package.
I've got to find something better than my old slide-rule for my number crunching.
JAG
Jag, have you considered an electronic calculator? They're remarkably cheap these days.
It might be my eyes, but the cross of st George looks to be at the very front of the union flag. Caledonia is at the back.
pittsy,
I would NEVER argue with a brit about the Union Jack!
I am sure you are correct.
After all I am just a humble backwoods colonial.
But you do all sound the same ;-)
EH!
JAG
Funnily enough it's a "myth" that the British themselves are happy to perpetuate when painting an idealised picture of a homogeneous national identity. John Major in 1993:
‘Fifty years on from now, Britain will still be the country of long shadows on cricket grounds, warm beer, invincible green suburbs, dog lovers and pools fillers and, as George Orwell said, “Old maids bicycling to Holy Communion through the morning mist.”’
Ironically, in the essay from which his quote was lifted Orwell (real surname: Blair) was actually arguing that even England on its own (as distinct from Britain) was not so readily capable of being reduced to defining stereotypes:
‘Are we not forty-six million individuals, all different? And the diversity of it, the chaos! The clatter of clogs in the Lancashire mill towns, the to-and-fro of the lorries on the Great North Road, the queues outside the Labour Exchanges, the rattle of pin-tables in the Soho pubs, the old maids hiking to Holy Communion through the mists of the autumn morning – all these are not only fragments, but characteristic fragments, of the English scene. How can one make a pattern out of this muddle?’
In a related twist of irony Mr Orwell also wrote an essay describing a fictitious idealised London pub titled The Moon Under Water, a name which went on to be appended, shamelessly, to several soulless fake-authentic lounge bars operated by a certain national chain…
Shuggs I didn't know you were from Jockshire, nice one! I drunk a bit of Guinness a few years ago after a RTA because my iron count was low and I thought it more fun than popping vitamin pills! I love the look of it, but I do struggle to drink anything heavier than gurlie lager, although I'm actually more of a wine drinker! P.s. I'm 'pretty sure' that England 'is' a country. That's what I always write in the box when asked on forms! I cheer anyone on from the UK in sports events!
I'm not missing the homeland much at all, but urban myths and in-factual stereotype assumptions can mildly frustrate! You know... the way many Brits incorrectly think all American's are obese, loud and rude; when I've probably seen more Brits that fit that actual description per headcount. And the way American's often think everyone in England drinks tea, eats crumpets in the afternoon, drinks warm beer in the evenings, London is always foggy and everyone either speaks like Dick Van Dyke or the Queen! :-D
The Panigale is going to be something else going by that first clean sheet since the 851 engine. I'm apparently being invited to some special pre-launch thing here. But a) we'll see if that happens or not and b) I've no idea why, as I'll not be buying one!
Jag I think the volumetric and calorific count would certainly outweigh the velocity factors. Only being English I'm not sure about Newfies ability to drink, but I've drunk with the Finns on the edge of the Arctic Circle and they make fish look tea total! I've looked closely at your union jack flag, but I still can't see the flag of St.George in there! ;-D
I'm not too up on Orwell, but Dean Martin once apparently said "You're not drunk if you can lie on the floor without holding on"
Has anyone seen Gemma Atkinson thrusting curves? ....
I'm not up on Orwell or Martin, but I do know dick van dyke once said
"step in toime, step in toime. Maywee pappins."
Cappy said,
"I've looked closely at your union jack flag, but I still can't see the flag of St.George in there! ;-D"
If you drink enough GOOD American ICE COLD lite beer "burp" and "burp" and close one eye "burp" and squint real hard with the other "burp" I think you can old St. George.
JAG
My 'escaping reality' kit is a bit depleted at the moment. I've only got one tin of Bud, one bottle of Blackthorn cider, some 100% proof Southern Comfort (good for the sinuses if you snort it), dark Bacardi, double-barrel single-malt scotch, and various chardonnays, pinot, shiraz and merlot in my starter castle right now. Perhaps if I mix a little of them altogether, in a pint glass, like some kind a mad Glaswegian whiskey-chaser it just might do the drink!
Right I'm off to make the missus pork pilaff... ooh I'm such a domestic goddess in the kitchen I am! ;-D
Captain - my sympathies about having even one can of Bud anyway near you. As I have said I lived in the USA and I am a real Amerophile but my God they can not make beer - that stuff truly is like making love in a canoe. The real and original Budweiser is a local brew to me now and boy oh boy is it a gazillion times better.
As for a "Glaswegian whiskey" anything. Shame on you sir how dare you spell the hallowed word with an e in it. There is no more whiskey in Glasgow than there are i-pods in a trappist monastery - whisky man, whisky - you have not been away that long.
Kev has panigale power/torque curve on his technical archive section.
Kevin's Panigale HP & Torque graph
I suspect the graph is based on crank HP and not RWHP.
The second problem is that the HP curve and torque curve cross at about 7000 RPM.
I thought the HP graph and torque graph should always cross at 5252 RPM based on the HP formula:
HP = (torque ft/lbs)(RPM)
--------------------
5252
If the torque is expressed as ftlb I suppose it would.
I suspect 750 watts as a constant creeps in here. Can't see graph very well and can't make out units. Suspect kgm or Nm. Would be easy to calculate to find out.
Or is it because they are using two different scales. One for power, one for torque.
If you look at what the torque figure is at 5252rpm, then read across to the left hand scale, it looks right.
Hi pittsy,
I think you are right.
The torque number in ft/lbs at about 5250 RPM and the crank HP at about 5250 RPM appear to be the same number.
I suspect the values are measured at the crank.
To calculate the RWHP we need a correction valve. Does your 10% loss sound reasonable?
Thanks,
JAG
I wouldn't think anyone really knows what the exact losses are. 10percent has to be fair in my eyes. I'm expecting the result to be something akin to a zx6 .......... . ON ACID!
Shuggs, I meant to write Glasga! I haven't opened the Balvenie "DoubleWood" 12 Year Matured Single Speyside Malt Scotch Whisky yet; might save that one for Christmas Day!
It's interesting how the scale says it's Lb.ft, but the line graph is clearly measuring Nm. Crank figures are extrapolated, but based on most manufacturers claims versus RWHP 10-15% loses are common. I suspect this will be particularly efficient in it's transference, equating to 10% or so as Pittsy surmises.
It'll be thereabouts in terms of class leading power, but should be a lighter bike based on the manufacturers claims. Although, and just like BMW, Ducati's weight claims do seem a bit subject to smoke and mirrors jiggery-pockery as we all know.
We could base the RWHP on a percentage of error based on the Diavel.
What did Ducati claimed as the maximum crank HP and what was actually measured as maximum RWHP?
The Diavel maximum measured RWHP I think was about 138. What did Ducati claim as the maximum RWHP?
If we know the true total weight of the 1198 with fuel can we assume it will be equal to or maybe a little lighter.
Can we assume the gear ratios will be about the same as the 1198?
That's a lot of assumptions and a lot of could be, might be, should be.
JAG
"What did Ducati claim as the maximum RWHP?"
... no manufacturer claims a rear wheel figure (more is the pitty), but the crank figure claim is 162 hp, so 20% or whatever. Depends what dyno you used of course, plus wind direction and speed, and if the operator had one trouser leg rolled up or not.
Your last three sentences use the word assume. I'll not elaborate! ;-D
A set of accurate scales, a most commonly certified and recently calibrated dyno, run in a environment controlled room at median ambient temperature, with disclaimed fuel octane rating and an actual bike wouldn't go a miss. Until we get those things, then the could, should and might will remain just that I suspect!
There's a lot of variables here, but one near constant is the same rider and rubber on the same day using a data logger to dissect average lap performance. But again until we have a bike...
I'm not clever enough to talk about thrust curves with any degree of technical ability, like many of the contributors probably can. But it does seem to me that the sooner we stop talking about unknown quantities (Panigale) and stick to known quantities (released bikes) the more relevant (accurate) the physics of the discussion will be. Don't want to highjack the thread, it was just a thought! :-D
"But it does seem to me that the sooner we stop talking about unknown quantities (Panigale) and stick to known quantities (released bikes) the more relevant (accurate) the physics of the discussion will be. Don't want to highjack the thread, it was just a thought! :-D"
I agree
JAG
I hope ducati's crank power figures include running the crankcase pump or that's just plain cheating! Incidentally, using a crankcase pump apparently has a compound effect on the gains. For example, as well as improving pumping losses and oil drag it allows the use of lower tension oil scraper rings, further lowering friction. Wonder what other subtle gains there are? These will all be offset against the power to run the pump though.
Cap'n, regarding your comment that the panigale transmission will be extra efficient, don't forget that the gains in efficiency talked about so far are to do with the "engine". So that will express itself in the crank power output anyway. The transmission may or may not have efficiency tricks up it's sleeve, but we need to be careful in assuming so. No?
Lower pressure will affect the oil seal friction, for the better, so maybe it will be better than the "average". Anyone know or think of other ways in which lower pressure will benefit a gearbox? Lowering the oil level beneath the gears and spraying oil into "the mesh" should improve friction/drag and allow higher speeds.
A neat trick would be altering the oil flow rate into the gear pairs according to which gear is selected. Improving efficiency. Neat! And a good use of electronics. I'm seeing a device like guitar pitch pipes, covering the appropriate hole to raise oil flow.
User login
Donate to the Kevin Ash Fund
Donate directly to the Kevin Ash Fund setup by the Telegraph to help with the education of his three daughters.
The Telegraph can only accept cheques and Postal Orders in Sterling. If you'd like to make a donation but you can't send a cheque or Postal Order then you might consider using PayPal, which will accept other methods of payment. A small percentage (about 3.4%) will be retained by PayPal for the service.
Kevin's family have been touched by the generosity and messages of support from people using the website and would like to express their gratitude to those who have contributed in any way.
The donations keep coming in, thank you so much, and the family especially like it when you leave a message.
Ads
NEWS...
* TRIUMPH TIGER SPORT
The Tiger gets a single-sided swingarm and another 10bhp!...(more)
* HONDA MSX125
Honda announces a spiritual successor to the iconic Monkey Bike!...(more)
* APRILIA CAPONORD
At last Aprilia goes for the GS too......(more)
* GUZZI CALIFORNIA 1400
Italy's biggest ever V-twin for the all-new Guzzi...(more)
* VESPA 946 FIRST PIC
Sleek new Vespa 125 based on last year's concept bike...(more)



I reckon! :)
Got a bit of static strain going on myself. Got pins stickng out of three toes. Not bike related. Very little mobility for 6 weeks. :(